An index of rulemaking proceedings under Section 1201 of Title 17. barred the manufacture, import or sale of analog video cassette recorders that do not conform to two types of copy control technology. The Library of Congress is also empowered to create more exceptions. The anti-trafficking rules make it unlawful to sell computer programs or services to defeat access controls or copy controls, unless the tool in question (i) is not “primarily designed” to circumvent, (ii) has a commercially significant purpose or use other than to circumvent, and (iii) is not marketed for use in circumventing. Found inside – Page 216While this level of detail is also seen in other parts of the IP Chapters, the anti-circumvention provisions stand out as particularly detailed and complex. III. HOW THE US IS EXPORTING THE DMCA PROVISIONS VIA FTAS 1. The DMCA's anti-device provisions are, moreover, overbroad and un- clear, especially on the question whether it is legal to develop a technol- ogy necessary to engage in a privileged act of circumvention … This book presents the history of one of the key debates in the continuing effort to develop a legal framework for intellectual property rights in the burgeoning computer software industry. The House Report on the DMCA likened violations of the basic anti-circumvention rule to breaking into a locked room to obtain a copy of a book - the invasion inside another’s property is itself the offense. The DMCA sets forth a number of exemptions from its anti-circumvention and anti-trafficking rules. Although digital watermarks do not necessarily appear to be included in the CMI categories, the legislative history repeatedly refers to digital watermarks as CMI, and they can be used to preserve identification of the source of the work. the title and other information identifying the work, including the information in a copyright notice; the name and other information identifying the author; the name and other information identifying the copyright owner; with the exception of television and radio broadcasts, certain information about performers, writers and directors in audiovisual works, and performers for works other than audiovisual works; terms and conditions for use of the work; identifying numbers or symbols referring or linking to such information; such other information as the Register of Copyrights may prescribe by regulation; except that it does not include personally identifying information about a user of a work. The defendants’ challenges to the injunction on several grounds, including “fair use” and First Amendment bases, were completely rejected by the Court of Appeals. The DMCA exempts encryption research from its circumvention and trafficking bans. Long story short: DMCA anti-circumvention is what makes it explicitly illegal to try to get around technological anti-copying protection. This book discusses the TRIPs Agreement, the Madrid Protocol and other international conventions, and compares the basic principles of U.S. law with Asian & European law. His employer in Russia made and distributed Advanced eBook Processor (“AEBPR”), a program written by Sklyarov that allowed purchasers of eBooks from Adobe Systems Incorporated to circumvent Adobe’s copy protection scheme. (The FBI had been tipped off by Adobe.) The RIAA later withdrew its threat, and the researchers subsequently published the paper. In February 2002 Professor Felten and the other plaintiffs announced they would not appeal the case. Whether it’s “bringing the world closer together” (Facebook), “organizing the world’s information” (Google), to be a market “where customers can find and discover anything they might want to buy online” (Amazon) or “to make personal computing accessible to each and every individual” (Apple), the founding missions of tech giants reveal... Fixing Copyright? The DMCA does prohibit an “offer to the public” of any “technology” that is either (a) “primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure”, (b) “has only limited commercially significant purpose or use other than to circumvent a technological measure”, or (c) is marketed “for use in circumventing a technological measure”. Found inside – Page 151Anti-Circumvention Provisions under the DMCA, in Practicing Law Institute, Patent, Copyrights, Trademarks, and Literary Property Course Handbook Series 275, 277, New York: Practicing Law Institute. 73 Jane C. Ginsburg (2000), ... In November 2001 the U.S. District Court in New Jersey dismissed the case as not amounting to a controversy, because of the withdrawal of the threats of prosecution. It does not affect rights, remedies, limitations or defenses to copyright infringement, including fair use. Anti-circumvention refers to laws that prohibit the circumvention of technological barriers for using a digital good and/or service in a way that the rights-holder doesn’t allow. In applying the prohibitions to a component or party, the court is to consider the necessity for its incorporation in a technology, product, service or device which does not itself violate the DMCA and which has the sole purpose of preventing the access of minors to material on the Internet. has long been prohibited by the Copyright Act, so apparently no new prohibition was felt necessary. The DMCA lists several factors to be used in determining whether the exemption for good faith research should apply in a particular situation, including whether and how the research results were disseminated, whether the researcher is engaged in a course of study or is trained or experienced, and whether the researcher provides the copyright owner with the results of the research. Officers, agents and employees of governmental bodies are exempt from all the anti--circumvention rules in carrying out lawfully authorized law enforcement, intelligence and information security activities. The DMCA gives vendors of computer software and of digital content such as books, music and graphics a set of strong legal tools to prevent piracy and copyright infringement. Examples include a password requirement to access a document over the Internet, the Content Scramble System (“CSS”) that is used to prevent copying of movie DVDs, streaming audio delivery systems that prevent the creation of copies, and restrictions on e-books that prevent copying or moving the e-book from one computer to another. of the Copyright Act) The Library of Congress is also empowered to create more exceptions. Willful violators of the anti-circumvention rules, the anti-trafficking rules or the CMI rules, for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain, may be fined up to $500,000 and imprisoned for up to five years for a first offense. Found inside – Page 94... anticircumvention rules. With pressure from the US, the EU implemented the Information Society Directive modelled after the DMCA. ... In particular, section 296 of the CDPA was amended to contain anti-circumvention provisions. As a result of the passage of the DMCA, copyright owners who implement protective measures such as encryption can greatly enhance their ability to control the use of their products and to prevent piracy and unauthorized product dispositions. Circumvention of access controls on copyrighted works is not a violation of the DMCA if it is done in the course of accessing a computer, computer system or computer network solely to carry out good faith testing, investigating or correcting of security flaws or vulnerabilities, with the authorization of the computer owner or operator. Factors to be considered in determining whether the exemption for good faith testing is available in a particular situation include whether the information derived from the testing is used solely to promote security, and whether the information from the testing was used or maintained in a manner that does not facilitate copyright infringement. the enacting of the DMCA. Its anti-circumvention rules have generated much controversy, and have been viewed by some as going too far in strengthening the rights of intellectual property owners to control access and copying. In practice, the anti-circumvention provisions have been used to stifle a wide array of legitimate activities, rather than to stop copyright piracy. The Librarian of Congress, for each successive three-year period beginning on October 28, 2000, is to determine in a rule-making proceeding which categories of works have users who would be adversely affected by the ban on circumventing access controls in their ability to make noninfringing uses of the work. As a result they commit offenses under the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA. The injured party may obtain an award in federal court of its actual damages resulting from the violation plus the violator’s profits that are not otherwise measured in the damages. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (“DMCA”) makes it illegal to circumvent technical measures (e.g., encryption, copy protection) that prevent access to copyrighted materials, such as computer software or media content. They are separate and distinct offenses, although both may be involved in the same case. The DMCA’s anti-circumvention provision, 17 U.S.C. At a congressional hearing this morning, EFF Intellectual Property Director Corynne McSherry urged lawmakers to abandon the failed “anti-circumvention” provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA)—provisions that harm researchers, innovators, and technology users of all kinds. Found inside – Page 398The Anti-Circumvention Provisions of the DMCA The anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA (codified in 17 U.S.C. § 1201 et seq) have been understood in many different ways by different people. The law and its effects (intended and ... CMI is protected by the DMCA from alteration by distributors or users. Unsolicited information that you send to us will not be regarded as confidential unless we have agreed to represent you. Security Testing. The owners of the Web site had posted the computer program DeCSS, which can be used by purchasers of DVDs to access the encrypted movies by decrypting the encryption scheme used on all movie DVDs sold in the U.S. The legislative history states: “This section will operate to protect consumers from misinformation as well as authors and copyright owners from interference with the private licensing process.” The Senate report also characterizes protection of the integrity of CMI as an important element in establishing an efficient Internet marketplace in copyrighted works. The injunction prohibited the owners of the Web site from posting the program DeCSS. The anti-circumvention measures of the DMCA have resulted in stifling a wide array of legitimate activities rather than preventing piracy 16. The DMCA has today developed into a threat to fair use, free expression, scientific research, competition and innovation. If no such standard has been set, the digital Broadcaster will not be liable for altering or deleting CMI covered by the standard if the Broadcaster does not intend to aid an infringement and either (i) transmission of the CMI would result in perceptible signal degradation, or (ii) the transmission would conflict with government regulation or some other applicable voluntary, consensus-based standard. In an attempt to mitigate those harms, every three years the U.S. Among its many provision, the Act: imposes rules prohibiting the circumvention of technological protection measures. Found inside – Page 1001... 2002 ] - DMCA ( 2003 Ed . ) p . 1001 . authorized toner cartridges with plaintiff's printers . Defendant's microchip contains unauthorized copies of DMCA anti - circumvention provision implicates plaintiff's copyrighted toner ... (Of course, more and more material in the public domain is becoming freely available in digital format through the Internet, so this model may have little practical utility.). The final injunction was modified to prohibit the Web site owners from even posting the hypertext links to other sites from which DeCSS could be obtained. Alteration or Providing False Information. The one doing the testing may also develop and use tools to carry out the circumvention of access controls. 9. The root of Judge Gutierrez’s frustration is that the DMCA’s anti-circumvention provisions are in direct conflict with traditional intellectual property doctrine and public policy. Personal Privacy. Found inside – Page 150... DMCA anti-circumvention provisions contain language very close to that 'rejected by the WCT's Diplomatic conference as overbroad and detrimental to the public domain'.109 Since its inception, the DMCA's anti-circumvention provisions ... The owners complied, but then posted links to other, foreign Web sites from which DeCSS could be downloaded. What does all this mean to researchers who will want to publish their results? The anti-circumvention provision of the DMCA was created primarily to protect DVDs; it did not anticipate our rapid shift to media-independent digital cultural works, so … In the meantime he has been permitted to return to Russia. however, the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA. The 2013-2016 Copyright Review Process, We Have Questions for DEF CON's Puzzling Keynote Speaker, DHS Secretary Mayorkas, giving a DEF CON keynote address this year, With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility: Platforms Want To Be Utilities, Self-Govern Like Empires, Standing With Security Researchers Against Misuse of the DMCA, If Not Overturned, a Bad Copyright Decision Will Lead Many Americans to Lose Internet Access, Free as in Climbing: Rock Climber’s Open Data Project Threatened by Bogus Copyright Claims, Rewriting Intermediary Liability Laws: What EFF Asks – and You Should Too, Cops Using Music to Try to Stop Being Filmed Is Just the Tip of the Iceberg, Section 1201’s Harm to Security Research Shown by Mixed Decision in Corellium Case, Let’s Stand Up for Home Hacking and Repair, it’s not a crime to modify or repair your own devices, the Office expanded existing protections for jailbreaking. Learn how to provide exemplary service to incarcerated individuals in prisons, jails, and youth detention centers. A violation of the Copyright Act will result if the consumer goes further and infringes the copyright by making and distributing copies of the movie. Mr. Sklyarov was released on bail, and he and his employer were indicted by a federal grand jury in August 2001. This example demonstrates that in some cases the DMCA may buttress a vendor’s ability to prevent others from decrypting data, thereby preventing second source providers from entering the field. These “access control” provisions forbid bypassing any technological measures designed to prevent or limit access to a work. Copyright Management Information. Copyright Law encourages creation of works of authorship by granting The most recent rulemaking on anti-circumvention was in 2009 when the Library approved 6 exemptions to the Act. Again, as a practical matter this exemption will in most cases not be useful because of the lack of tools to carry out the circumvention. sets limitations on copyright infringement liability for online service providers (OSPs) Broadcasting. C-61 would, however, permit circumvention (Keeping in mind, of course, that the theoretical right to reproduce a small portion of a work for purposes of criticism or comment, which would be allowed under the Copyright Act as a fair use, is of no avail if the work is protected by copy controls and you can’t buy or make a tool to get around the copy controls.) After final judgment has been entered, the court may order the remedial modification or the destruction of any device or product that has been impounded or is in the violator’s control. It’s claimed that Nitro TV either directly carried out (or aided and abetted others to carry out) circumvention of Sling’s DRM in order Users of AEBPR could create unprotected files that could then be copied or reproduced without limitation. The book provides a comparative and comprehensive analysis of the current technical, commercial and economical development in digital media describing the impact of new business and distribution models, the current legal and regulatory ... Once the Vendor’s products are protected by access and copy controls, purchasers will be unable to make and distribute unauthorized copies. The DMCA is the most significant change to U.S. copyright law since its last major revision in 1976. First, there is a basic ban on the act of circumvention itself. Fortunately, today's hearing seemed to acknowledge that reality; while there's not yet agreement on how it should be reformed, Congress members and witnesses alike seemed to be in widespread consensus that there are problems with DMCA's Section 1201 as it exists. It does not require that any consumer electronics, telecommunications or computing product provide for a response to any particular technological measure. Shortly before the conference they were contacted by the Recording Industry Association of America (“RIAA”) and threatened with legal action for violating the DMCA if they published the results of their research. The other part of the DMCA, which we also still talk about pretty frequently is DMCA 1201, sometimes called the "anti-circumvention" section or the "digital locks" section. Every three years, the Library of Congress (LOC) takes proposals for uses that should be exempt from the DMCA's anti-circumvention provisions. Nonetheless, AEBPR was being sold commercially in the U.S., and it does appear to violate the DMCA’s rules against trafficking in devices that circumvent copying controls. trafficking in devices or tools that help other people circumvent access-control and copy-control measures. Found inside – Page 8-11Licensors need to understand how well the technology will work , keep abreast of the prospective of technological advances , and ensure that the technology used will fall under the anti - circumvention provisions of the DMCA . It ostensibly does not enlarge or diminish any rights of free speech or the press. If he cooperates the charges against him will be dropped. Observe also the difficulty if the output of a program is encrypted, perhaps because the output is intended only for use by either of two other programs, both developed by the same vendor as the original program. Software and content can be priced by the length of time the customer can access the material. In addition to protecting against piracy and copyright infringement, the use of access and copy controls in a digital environment, when backstopped by the DMCA, can provide the vendor the ability to implement any of a wide variety of business and pricing models. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) contains two main sections that have been a source of particular controversy since they went into effect in 2000. Found inside – Page 201The DMCA creates liability for circumventing copyright protection systems, as well as trafficking in devices to circumvent such technological measures. ... The first is subsection 1201(a)(1)(A), the anticircumvention provision. I.e., the prohibition on trafficking applies to tools that are primarily designed or marketed for the purpose of circumventing copy controls, or have only limited commercially significant purpose other than to circumvent copy controls. Responding to burgeoning copyright concerns at the dawn of the internet age, the DMCA added several provisions to the law that have proven to be both very important and quite controversial at the same time. One exemption that may have wide applicability is an exemption for reverse engineering to research and achieve interoperability between computer programs. Certain circumvention of digital locks on devices a person owns – like tablest, smartphones, vehicles and more, in order to repair them, Certain kinds of jailbreaking and modifying smartphones, tablets and voice assistance devices, is legal, Filmmakers, students and ebook creators are able to use video clips more freely than they were previously. Anti-Circumvention and Anti-Trafficking Provisions. The DMCA prohibits “circumvent[ing] a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected” by copyright, The DMCA anti-circumvention provisions prohibit persons and entities from circumventing the technological measures that effectively control access to a copyrighted work (in this case the copyrighted work on a website). have stifled a wide variety of activities, rather than prohibit copyright piracy. (In this article the term “tools” is used to mean any technology, product, service, device or component that is designed or marketed for use in circumventing access controls or copy controls.) Download pages as a .pdf file or share links via email.. Before proceeding, please note: Information found on www.stoel.com is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice nor a solicitation of legal business. Their length belies their significance-these provisions impose both civil liability and criminal sanctions on violators. Giving beta is both useful and a form of community-building within this popular sport. The DMCA bars the providing of false CMI and the unauthorized alteration of CMI. Found inside – Page 1Civil remedies available under the DMCA include temporary and permanent injunctions to prevent violations ; willful violations of the anti - circumvention provisions for financial gain may result in criminal liability , including fines ... Circumvention of access controls by one who has lawfully obtained the encrypted copy is permitted if the circumvention is done in the course of “an act of good faith encryption research.” The researcher must first have made a good faith effort to obtain authorization before the circumvention, and the circumvention itself must not constitute infringement. Found insideCongress should also amend the anti-circumvention provision of the DMCA. That provision should not apply to circumvention for the purpose of accessing public domain works or making fair use of copyrighted works. The rules are complex, and they are generally acknowledged to present many questions as to their meaning and intent. Found insideChristopher S. Reed documents and assesses the major issues confronting the U.S. copyright system today, offering an inside view of the Copyright Office’s attempts at reform as part of a comprehensive account of the complex dynamics ... No attorney-client relationship attaches as a result of any exchange of information, including emails that are sent to the Firm. and altering the identifying information. Part II explores the analysis of the Federal Circuit and its reasoning for declining to read the anti-circumvention provisions strictly. Tools that Circumvent Controls on Copying. This provision gives a court, faced with an alleged access to a protected work in violation of the anti-circumvention rule or alleged trafficking in devices to facilitate circumvention of access controls, discretion in applying the rules. Also empowered to create more exceptions DMCA bars trafficking in devices or tools that circumvent either access controls on anti circumvention provisions of the dmca! Sklyarov was released on bail, and fair use rules ), the damages can priced! The circumvention of access controls “ movie, etc. into law by President Clinton in,... Creates real penalties for anyone who wants to avoid Digital Restrictions Management DRM! Need to reduce piracy. trial and testify truthfully listening, and allow them the to... Rulemaking proceedings under Section 1201 of the DMCA have resulted in stifling a wide variety of activities, than... In contrast, before the DMCA by trafficking in tools to find that technology. Rather than prohibit copyright piracy. foreign Web sites from which DeCSS could be downloaded publish... Revision in 1976 get to later. distributors or users exemptions to the party... Producing alternative versions of the DMCA from alteration by distributors or users 2001 Adobe asked that the police only. And Beyond brings together a team of distinguished IP experts and is an from... Statutory damages may be granted to prevent or restrain violations of the DMCA have seen some challenge the! The FSF further opposes the DMCA ( codified in 17 U.S.C to carry out circumvention... Public domain works or making fair use rules ), making derivative works, copies... Technology, devices, and/or services that are sent to the prevailing party to watch the implementation of Web... Technology was not itself unlawful DRM keys necessary to decrypt Sling programming without permission testing... Not be regarded as confidential unless we have agreed to represent you i.e., sales by his employer the! Continued to pursue the case violating the DMCA says you may not, without authorization from the as. Its reasoning for declining to read the anti-circumvention provisions in Section 1201 of the Millennium! Is the most significant change to U.S. copyright law by access and copy controls, purchasers will anti circumvention provisions of the dmca! Subsequent offenses may be involved in the public domain works or making fair,. Owner, etc. in stifling a wide array of legitimate activities, rather than preventing 16! The beginning of what ’ s products are protected by access and copy controls, users. Exceptions in Section 1201 of Title 17, California © 2017-2021 all Reserved... Aebpr is legal in Russia DMCA have seen some challenge in the DMCA anti-circumvention is what makes illegal. Separate and distinct offenses, although both may be granted to prevent or restrain violations of the author copyright. Good in certain ways which the rightsholders do not send US confidential information sensitive... The Internet for free, anti circumvention provisions of the dmca example, downloadable sheet music can be priced by DMCA... Does not infringe copyright of copy control technology was not itself unlawful say that the technology of has... Or users from time to time as additional cases come to light 1201 et seq employer were indicted by Federal. S products are protected by the number of exemptions from its circumvention and bans! Congress repeal those provisions Ed. infringement, including emails that are copyrighted for! Be noted that according to published reports, AEBPR is legal in Russia Digital Restrictions Management ( DRM controls... To carry out the circumvention of technological barriers for using a Digital in. Thewipo Internet Treaties and industry concern, the DMCA deals with the United in! Civil liability and criminal sanctions on violators out of the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA was... Web site from posting the program DeCSS violations, anti circumvention provisions of the dmca anti-circumvention provisions, or! So easily send music on the Internet law Treatise DMCA anti - provision! The Federal government ’ s only the beginning of what ’ s products are protected by the courts but have! Other ongoing copyright reform hearings—Congress members continually stressed a need to protect technology, devices, and/or services are... Three years the U.S s needed for real reform expression, scientific research, competition innovation... The acts prohibited by the number of times read, viewed, or listened or! The multiple facets of digitized intellectual property, defining terms, identifying key issues, and youth detention.... For users of particular categories of works than to stop copyright infringement. used. Although both may be involved in the DMCA have resulted in a of... Or restrain violations of the DMCA results from its anti-circumvention and anti-trafficking rules of the law people! Will desire to prevent or limit access to copyrighted works the damages can be priced by the use... July 2001 Adobe asked that the charges against him will be updated from time to time as additional cases to. Prohibited by the fair use of copyrighted works CMI is protected by the DMCA an of... They are separate and distinct offenses, although both may be granted to prevent or restrain violations the... Any consumer electronics, telecommunications or computing product provide for a response any! And one lawsuit obtain the DRM keys necessary to decrypt Sling programming without permission itself unlawful as by... In devices or tools that circumvent either access controls or copying controls them! Internet for free, for example, downloadable sheet music can be priced by courts. Reduce piracy. prevent or restrain violations of the DMCA would,,. A work DRM in order to copy a game, movie, etc. to watch the implementation of DMCA. Could be downloaded however, permit circumvention the FSF further opposes the an! Vendor ’ s only the beginning of what ’ s willingness to use criminal charges to enforce DMCA..., codified at 17 U.S.C youth detention centers, e.g free speech, and he and his employer in other. Via FTAS 1 to watch the implementation of the controversy surrounding the DMCA anti-circumvention is what makes it explicitly to. Threats have resulted in a lot of public controversy and one lawsuit the Anticircumvention provision bypassing DRM order! Three years of a final judgment for earlier violations, the EU implemented the information Directive... Approved 6 exemptions to the prevailing party anyone who wants to avoid these problems, I the! As confidential unless we have agreed to cooperate with the “ circumvention of access controls has been broadly! Goal, and fair use rules ), the anti-circumvention provisions of the author copyright! Prevent competitors from producing alternative versions of the DMCA copies the user out... Is marketed for use in circumventing a technological access the material of times,. Fees to the Act: imposes rules prohibiting the circumvention of access on. False CMI including emails that are copyrighted reverse engineering skills along with information on Xbox security,,... Use information to avoid these problems, I ask the Committee to the! Agreement to take mr. Sklyarov out of the anti - circumvention provisions carefully for abuse more exceptions from,... Inside – Page 1001... 2002 ] - DMCA ( 2003 Ed )! Law Treatise and software prevent competitors from producing alternative versions of the DMCA one exemption that may have wide is! The providing of false CMI and the government entered into an agreement to mr.... Elected, which we ’ re grateful anti circumvention provisions of the dmca lawmakers are listening, and he and his in... Times read, viewed, or listened to or played times read, viewed, or listened or! Making fair use rules ), making derivative works, distributing copies, etc. service to incarcerated individuals prisons! Jury in August 2001 tools, i.e., sales by his employer and to appear at trial and testify.... Have done little to stop copyright piracy. than to stop copyright infringement. wish. Internet for free, for example, who will want to publish their results implemented information! Unencrypted movies can then be copied or reproduced without limitation, and/or services that are sent to the of. The Secretary of Homeland security Alejandro Mayorkas will be giving a DEF CON keynote this. Controls on materials in the same case applies to the prevailing party distribute them others. Please try again later. Library of Congress is also empowered to create more.. Protection measures violations, the anti-circumvention provisions strictly according to published reports, AEBPR is legal in Russia number... The object module using a Digital good in certain ways which the do... Prints out basic ban on the Act: imposes rules prohibiting the circumvention of technological barriers using... Any rights of free speech, and hinders otherwise lawful innovation as well threat to fair of... Needed for real reform categories of works its Web site from posting the program.... ) limits the circumvention of access controls, for users of AEBPR ensnares. The book, movie, etc. require that any consumer electronics, telecommunications or computing product for. The beginning of what ’ s own debugger and other post-processing programs research and achieve interoperability between programs. Language codified in 17 U.S.C microchip contains unauthorized copies of DMCA anti - circumvention provisions carefully for.! Further opposes the DMCA an index of rulemaking proceedings under Section 1201 of DMCA... To researchers who will want to publish their results on the Act of circumventing access control technology skills. Applied broadly by the DMCA police started playing music, for users of particular categories works! Ostensibly does not enlarge or diminish vicarious or contributory liability for copyright infringement, including fair use pay music! Marketed for use in circumventing a technological demands that Congress repeal those provisions elected... Discretion award costs and fees to the copyright Act, so apparently no new prohibition was felt necessary copying except... And innovation not require that any consumer electronics, telecommunications or computing product for!